Certified Payroll Audits: What to Expect and How to Prepare

Certified payroll audits can be a significant challenge for construction workforce management teams. These audits, mandated for contractors working on federally funded projects, ensure workers receive the correct prevailing wages and benefits. While essential, audits can be time-consuming and disruptive. This post will guide you through the audit process, offering tips to prepare your records and minimize stress.

Need software to manage your time, HR, & certified payroll? Get a FREE DEMO of eBacon today!

Why are Certified Payroll Audits Conducted?

Certified payroll audits are conducted by the Department of Labor (DOL) to verify compliance with the Davis-Bacon and Related Acts. These laws require contractors to pay workers the prevailing wage rate for their specific job classification. The DOL examines payroll records to confirm accurate reporting of hours worked, wages paid, and fringe benefits provided.

What to Expect During Certified Payroll Audits

A certified payroll audit can be a stressful experience. The DOL requests various documents, including payroll records, timecards, employee classification documents, and project-specific information. Auditors interview employees and supervisors to verify payroll data accuracy.

The audit process can take several weeks or months. The DOL thoroughly reviews your records, potentially requesting additional documentation or clarification. If discrepancies arise, you’ll have an opportunity to explain your position.

Potential Findings of Certified Payroll Audits

Common audit findings include:

• Incorrect Wage Rates: Determining the correct wage rate is complex due to factors like location, job classification, and fringe benefits. Applying the wrong wage rate to an employee is a common mistake. For example, paying a laborer a carpenter’s rate.
• Fringe Benefit Calculations: Fringe benefits, such as health insurance, pension contributions, and vacation pay, can be challenging to calculate accurately. Errors in determining their value or applying them correctly can lead to audit findings.
• Employee Misclassification: Distinguishing between employees and independent contractors is crucial. Misclassifying employees as independent contractors to avoid payroll taxes and benefits is a common violation. Understand IRS and Department of Labor guidelines for worker classification.
• Overtime Pay Errors: Calculating overtime pay correctly can be complex, especially for employees with varying work schedules. Mistakes in determining the regular rate of pay or calculating overtime hours can result in audit findings.
• Kickbacks: Employees being required to return a portion of their wages to the employer is illegal and can lead to severe penalties.
• Withholding of wages: Failing to pay employees for all hours worked or for accrued benefits is a serious violation of labor laws.

Penalties for Violations of Certified Payroll Audits

Penalties for certified payroll violations can be very severe. The DOL can assess back wages, liquidated damages, and give civil penalties. Additionally, the DOL may debar your company from bidding on future federal contracts. In severe cases, criminal charges can be brought against individuals responsible for the violations.

How to Prepare for Certified Payroll Audits

Maintaining accurate and complete payroll records is crucial for preparing for a certified payroll audit. This involves:

• Accurate timekeeping: Ensure all employees accurately record their hours worked, including start and stop times, meal breaks, and overtime.
• Proper employee classification: Classify employees correctly as hourly, salaried, or exempt, following federal and state labor laws.
• Accurate wage calculations: Calculate wages and overtime pay correctly, considering all applicable wage rates and premium pay requirements.
• Complete payroll records: Maintain detailed payroll records, including timecards, pay stubs, pay registers, and employee classification documents.
• Regular reviews: Conduct regular internal audits of your payroll records to identify and correct potential problems.

Additional Tips for Preparing for Certified Payroll Audits

• Train your employees: Educate employees about the importance of accurate timekeeping and potential payroll error consequences.
• Document your wage determination process: Keep detailed records of how you determine prevailing wage rates, including sources and calculations.
• Maintain good communication with subcontractors: Ensure subcontractors comply with certified payroll requirements and provide necessary documentation.
• Consider payroll software: Invest in payroll software to maintain accurate records, generate compliant reports, and assist with audit preparation.

Common Audit Mistakes

Understanding common audit mistakes helps proactively address potential issues. Frequent errors include:

• Timecard discrepancies: Inaccurate or incomplete timecards are a major red flag. Ensure timecards are clear, accurate, and include necessary job information.
• Missing or incomplete payroll records: The absence of essential documents can hinder the audit process. Maintain complete payroll records.
• Subcontractor issues: Ensure subcontractors understand certified payroll requirements and provide necessary documentation.
• Math errors: Double-check wage rates, overtime calculations, and fringe benefit contributions for accuracy.
• Record retention: Retain payroll records for the required period to avoid penalties.

The Importance of Recordkeeping

Meticulous recordkeeping is essential for a smooth audit. Document everything, including:

• Timecards with detailed job information and hours worked
• Payroll registers with employee names, rates, deductions, and fringe benefits
• Wage determinations and supporting documentation
• Fringe benefit plans and contributions
• Employee classification documents
• Correspondence with subcontractors about certified payroll compliance

Technology and Payroll

Payroll software such as eBacon software can streamline the audit process. Look for software that:

• Automatically calculates wages and overtime
• Generates accurate and compliant payroll reports
• Stores electronic timecards and other documents
• Integrates with time and attendance systems

Subcontractor Management

Effectively managing subcontractors is crucial for certified payroll compliance. Implement the following:

• Clear contracts: Outline certified payroll responsibilities in subcontractor agreements.
• Regular communication: Maintain open communication with subcontractors about compliance requirements.
• Documentation: Collect and maintain certified payroll records from subcontractors.

Post-Audit Actions

If your business undergoes a certified payroll audit, follow these steps:

• Review findings: Carefully review the audit findings and understand the DOL’s concerns.
• Develop a corrective action plan: Create a plan to address any identified issues.
• Appeal if necessary: If you disagree with the findings, explore appeal options.
• Implement preventive measures: Take steps to prevent similar issues in the future.

Industry Best Practices for Certified Payroll Compliance

Adhering to industry best practices can significantly enhance your certified payroll compliance and reduce the risk of audit findings. Here are some essential guidelines:

Stay Informed About Regulations

• Monitor federal and state labor laws: Stay updated on changes to wage and hour laws, including prevailing wage rates and overtime regulations.
• Understand project-specific requirements: Familiarize yourself with the specific wage determinations applicable to your projects.
• Attend industry conferences and webinars: Participate in industry events to stay informed about emerging trends and compliance challenges.

Build a Strong Internal Compliance Program

• Develop clear policies and procedures: Create detailed guidelines for timekeeping, payroll processing, record retention, and employee classification.
• Conduct regular internal audits: Implement a system of regular internal audits to identify and correct potential compliance issues.
• Train employees: Educate employees about certified payroll requirements, their role in compliance, and the importance of accurate timekeeping.

Leverage Technology

• Utilize payroll software: Employ payroll software with features like automated wage calculations, time and attendance tracking, and report generation.
• Implement timekeeping systems: Use electronic timekeeping systems to improve accuracy and reduce the risk of timecard manipulation.
• Securely store electronic records: Maintain electronic payroll records in a secure, accessible, and compliant manner.

Foster a Culture of Compliance

• Open communication: Encourage open communication between management, payroll staff, and employees about certified payroll requirements.
• Employee hotline: Establish a confidential hotline for employees to report potential violations or concerns.
• Performance metrics: Develop key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure payroll compliance and identify areas for improvement.

Collaborate with Industry Associations

• Join relevant industry associations: Membership in construction industry associations provides access to resources, training, and networking opportunities. Below are some helpful organizations to look into –
  • Associated General Contractors of America (AGC)
  • National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)
  • Mechanical Contractors Association of America (MCAA)
• Participate in industry initiatives: Engage in collaborative efforts to improve industry-wide compliance practices.

Seek Expert Advice

• Consult with legal counsel: Seek legal advice on complex wage and hour issues.
• Engage payroll professionals: Consider hiring a payroll service provider with expertise in certified payroll compliance.

By incorporating these industry best practices into your business operations, you can significantly enhance your certified payroll compliance posture and mitigate the risks associated with audits.

Certified Payroll Audits are Necessary

Certified payroll audits are a necessary part of the construction industry. By understanding the audit process, maintaining accurate records, and proactively addressing potential issues, you can significantly reduce the stress and risk associated with audits. Remember, prevention is key.

The material presented here is educational in nature and is not intended to be, nor should be relied upon, as legal or financial advice. Please consult with an attorney or financial professional for advice.